Skip to main content

A Response to Maulana Umar Sahib

[This article is the second part of the series on 'Kerala Ahmadis and the New Mujaddid'. The first part was published yesterday, May 14, 2011 and can be accessed here. The series of articles analyses the strategies deployed by the Ahmadiyya leadership to put out the Light of Allah in the form of the new Mujaddid in Mauritius and his disciples in Kerala].   

Maulana Muhammad Umar Sahib is currently the Naib Nazir A’la, Sadr Anjuman Ahmadiyya, Qadian. He is one of the leading scholars of the Indian Ahmadiyya Jamaat and among the first to officially respond to the coming of a Mujaddid in our times. Soon after the Jamaat Ul Sahih Al Islam was formed and legally registered as an organization in Kerala, he wrote an article entitled “Khilafat and Mujaddidiyat” in the December 2010 issue of Sathyadoothan,  the official Ahmadiyya Journal. In spite of his profound learning and remarkable scholarship, the Maulana Sahib has come up with a deeply disturbing argument.  In the editorial abstract of the article, it is written: The coming of Mujaddidin is irrelevant because the Khilafat system established by the Mahdi Massih is thriving.(Sathyadoothan, p.13).

As a common Muslim, I cannot help but ask the Maulvi Sahib:

Who is the Mahdi Massih to interfere with the Sunnat of Allah and to abolish Khilafat-e-Muhammadiyya and replace it with Khilafat-e-AhmadiyyaOnce, a prayer of the Promised Massih (as) was not answered favourably by Allah the Most High. So the Promised Messiah (as) declared his intention to try intercession. On this Allah told him:  “Who was he to intercede without being granted permission to do so? The Promised Messiah (as) was left trembling upon this.

So, it is impossible to consider that the Mahdi Massih (as) has taught anything against the Sunnat of Allah. The raising of Divine reformers in every age is a permanent Sunnat of Allah- remember, 1, 24, 000 prophets and countless seers and saints preceded the coming of the Holy Prophet of Islam. It is completely unfair to allege that the Massih (as) has ended the chain of Mujaddidin who are the divinely appointed Khulafa of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa) or that he replaced the Mujaddidin with his own man-elected Khulafa till the Day of Judgement.

In the May 2011 Issue of the Sathyadoothan, Maulana Sahib is back with a new formulation of his thesis. The article now is entitled: “Khilafat: A Permanent Divine Institution”. The Maulvi Sahib quotes from Shahad-ul-Qur’an, the book of Hadhrat Ahmad (as) to reinforce his point on Khilafat. Yet, he did not see the following statement in the same book on the significance of Mujaddidin:

“It should be remembered that the perfection of faith does not dispense with the need of safeguarding it…These people do not reflect that the completion of a structure is one thing and its seasonal cleaning is quite another. It should be remembered that Mujaddidin do not add anything to or subtract any thing from the faith. They restore to the hearts that which had been lost. To assert that it is not necessary to believe in Mujaddidin is disobedience of a Divine command. He has directed: Whoever rejects the Khulafa, after they have been sent, is indeed from amongst the sinners’ (24: 56).  [Shahadat-ul-Qur’an, Ruhani Khaza’in, vol.6, pp.339-352]

The Maulvi Sahib is grossly erred in his understanding of what he is talking about. This is evident from his formulation of Mujaddidiyat and Khilafat as separate, temporary and permanent institutions. According to the Maulvi Sahib, Khilafat and Mujaddidiyat are two separate institutions designed to fly the flag of Islam in times of spiritual crisis. He states: “For this purpose, Allah has established two systems: First, a temporary arrangement and secondly, a permanent system is institutionalized. These are, respectively, the emergence of the Mujaddidin or religious revivalists on temporary basis and the Institution of Khilafat, which is a permanent institution”.

So, Mujaddidiyat is a temporary institution which happened to last 1400 long years! And Khilafat is the permanent institution that survived for a period of 30 years after the death of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sa). This “permanent” institution vanished into thin air for a mere 1400 years only to make an appearance after the arrival of the Mahdi-Massih (as). How can a permanent institution be non-existing? The searing irony can only be lost on those don’t want to see it. 

What was the fate of Islam in between? According to the Maulana, Islam could not produce noble souls who could be given the promise of Khilafat for a period of 1400 years till the departure of Mahdi Massih (as)! It really needs the extraordinary learning of a great scholar like him to wish away the glaring contradictions of his thesis! While the Maulvi Sahib has said that Mujaddidiyyat is a temporary institution, the Promised Massih (as) commenting on a verse of the Holy Qur’an said the very opposite:

"Another point is that the letter ra in the word alif-lam-ra shows that this word refers to the permanent institution of Mujaddidin and the sent ones, which will continue till the Day of Judgment. . . . All these miraculous works and victories which took place at the hands of the Mujaddidin among the followers of the Holy Prophet Muhammad after him, and will continue till the Day of Judgment, are really the achievements of the Holy Prophet." (Ruhani Khaza'in no. 2, vol. 2, p.63.)

Whom to follow? The choice is unmistakable: the Naib Nazir A’la or the Mahdi Massih (as)? The hapless ordinary Ahmadis, having sold their reason and intellect to their leaders and scholars, are condemned to swallow what they are told!

Reflect on what Allah says in the Holy Qur'an:

On that day when their faces are turned over into the fire, they will say “Oh would that we had obeyed Allah and the Messenger! And they will say ‘Our Lord we obeyed our chiefs and our great ones and they led us astray from the way, Our Lord give them double punishment and curse them with a mighty curse”. [HQ 33: 67-69]

For other articles in the series, click here: 3 and 4


Popular posts from this blog

'Surah Al- Fil': A Commentary

Holy Qur'an, Chapter 105: Al-Fil
1. In the Name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. 2. Have you not seen how your Lord dealt with the companions (i.e., owners) of the elephant? 3. Did He not make their treacherous plan go astray? 4. And He sent against them Birds in flocks, 5. Striking them with stones of hard-baked clay. 6. Then did He make them like an empty field of stalks and straw, (of which the crops) has been eaten up.
The Fate of Hubris: A Lesson from History
This Surah was revealed at Mecca in the early days of the prophethood of Hazrat Muhammad (pbuh). It speaks about the event that took place in the year of the birth of the Holy Prophet (saws), around the year 570 of the Christian calendar.Yemen at that time was under the control of the Abyssinians who were Christians and the latter had driven out the Jewish government that was in power at that time. Abraha Al-Ashram was the governor or Viceroy of Abyssinia. The thirst for power led him to self-proclaim himself king…

'Surah Al-Takathur': A Commentary

1. In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. 2. The race for (an increase in) wealth distracts you 3. until you visit the graves. 4. But no! You will soon know! 5. Again, You will soon know! 6. No! If you only knew with knowledge of certainty... 7. You will certainly see the Furnace. 8. Then you will certainly see it, with the eye of certainty. 9. Then, surely, you will be questioned that day about the delights (which you used to enjoy on this earth).
Competing for More
This chapter, Surah At-Takaathur (Ch.102) - Cupidity (i.e., the desire to have more and more) contains a warning to those who wish to possess everything, those who like to accumulate wealth.
Verse 2:‘Alhaakumut-Takaathuur - The race for (an increase in) wealth distracts you;
This fanaticism to acquire wealth and to increase one's fortune, position, the number of one's adherents, disciples or supporters, mass production or organization, affects not only one person but Societies and Nations.
What is called &…

Significance of Surah Al Fatiha

... I have chosen to talk/explain today on a never-ending subject. I can say that if the ocean was ink and all trees in this world and the universe were pens and the sky and earth were papers, therefore all these would have come to an end but not the commentary of the Surah Al-Fatiha. This is because of the high importance of this chapter in the life of a believer, and this chapter is the first chapter of the Holy Quran. It is so important that one has to start with the Surah Al-Fatiha when he begins his prayer (Namaz/Salat). And to start supplications (duahs) to Allah, the Surah Al-Fatiha needs to be recited first. This is because of the nature of its greatness as a chapter and duah. In whatever situation a person may be, be it a difficulty, an illness or a state of suffering or any other problems he finds himself in, therefore he needs to recite the Surah Al-Fatiha.
By the grace of Allah, today 22nd August 2014, I have thought about explaining a bit again on this very important chap…